Reconsider Your Florida Single Member LLC

A Florida single-member LLC is formed just like a multi-member LLC. You file the Articles of Organization with the Division of Corporations and pay the appropriate fee. Obviously, the major difference with a single-member LLC is that there is only one member. But this distinction has created a serious consequence for Florida business owners.

The primary protection offered by the LLC entity structure is that it provides limited liability protection for members. In other words, the entity shields members from creditors in various ways.

For example, if a member of a Florida LLC is sued and a creditor seeks payment for debts, the assets of the LLC cannot be seized in order to pay for the debt because these assets also belong, at least in part, to other members. As well, should the LLC itself be sued, a creditor cannot seize the personal assets of LLC members as a means of paying the debt.

In these cases, creditors are generally held to using what are called charging orders to remedy debt collection. What is a charging order? A charging order is an order issued by a court directing an LLC's manager to pay to the debtor-owner's personal creditor any distributions of income or profits that would otherwise be distributed to the debtor-member. Pay attention to the fact that creditors in Florida can only obtain the owner-debtor’s financial rights with the charging order - they cannot participate in the actual management of the LLC.  Thus, the creditor cannot order the LLC to make a distribution to the debtor/member. This makes the charging order a weak remedy for a creditor. 

Unfortunately, in 2010, the Florida Supreme Court found that the charging order limitation does not apply to single-member LLCs in Florida. This means that any Florida single-member LLC is not treated by the court system like other LLCs, but instead like a sole proprietorship. (Olmstead v. Federal Trade Commission). In a worst-case scenario, a creditor seeking repayment from a single-member LLC in Florida could seize control of the company, redirect distributions and liquidate assets until the debt is paid.

To avoid application of Florida’s single member LLC rules and obtain the fullest limited liability possible, a Florida LLC should have at least two members. The second member can be a spouse or relative as long as that person is treated as a legitimate co-owner of the LLC. If the second owner is added merely on paper as a sham, the courts will likely treat the LLC as a single member LLC. To avoid this, the co-owner must pay fair market value for the interest acquired and otherwise be treated as a "real" LLC member--that is, receive financial statements, participate in decision making, and receive a share of the LLC profits equal to the membership percentage owned.

Unfortunately, the majority of real estate professionals create single member LLC's, but this is an easy fix, and worth the minimal time and money invested in the correction. Call Richards Law Firm, PA to make the change and get your LLC documents in order. 


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Example of how House Bill 631 will help Buy and Hold Investors

The Florida Legislature Strengthens Laws to Remove Unwanted Parties from Your Property  The governor signed House Bill 631 into law on March 8, 2018, to update Florida law on ejectment, unlawful detainer, and customary use.   So what does this mean? First, let’s suppose the company owning the building next to yours puts up a fence ten feet over your property line, claiming to have a recorded deed to a strip of your land.  You think the deed is bogus.  To get rid of the fence you would likely file an “ejectment” action.  “Ejectment” is a kind of eviction action in which the party in possession claims a right to be there under a written instrument in its chain of title (usually a deed, easement, or other serious title instrument).  An ejectment action gives you the chance to prove your superior title to the property (after which you would  eject  the neighbor’s fence). Case closed.  The amendments to the Bill modernize the statute to clarify the process and documents necessary to es
Read more

A Blog Series On Land Trusts: Intro

I firmly believe Land Trusts are one of the most misunderstood real estate investment tools nationwide. My plan it to make this a series of posts that will touch on what a land trust is and what it is not, clear up myths and misconceptions and pass along some tips and tricks. It will be basic, but if you understand the basics you can then start to get really specific and use them to cater to your particular investment portfolio.  I haven’t decided how many parts will be in the series so my plan is to just take one topic at a time and see where it leads. First, my back ground with these creatures: If I had to pick something that was “my thing” it would probably be Land Trusts. Never would I have  imagined when I graduated law school this would be the case, but about 6 years ago Debbie Farnell of Southeast Professional Title handed me Mark Warda’s book on the subject and my gears have been turning ever since. In those 6 years or so I have drafted hundreds of land trusts, give
Read more

Must Read For Florida Foreclosure Auction Investors

As promised, here are the cliff notes for a recent 4 th District Court of Appeals case that interpreted the Lis Pendens statute and how it applied to a foreclosure case. Warning: its super boring, dry, legal talk, but if you purchase foreclosure properties it is a MUST READ. The basic timeline for the facts of this case are as follows: -         Bank filed a Lis Pendens (LP)  against a property they were foreclosing. -      .  Sometime around September 2008 the bank obtained a final judgment -        Beginning in July of 2009 – October 2011 the Town recorded 7 liens against the property for various code violations. -        The house sold at auction in 2012. -         In 2013, James Ober, the winning bidder at foreclosure auction filed suit to quiet title, attempting to strike the Town liens against his property. The case trudged through the court system and on August 26, 2016 the 4 th Circuit Court of Appeals for the State of Florida held, “[As] to liens placed on p
Read more