Subject to Mortgage vs. Assumption of Mortgage


Considering the shortage of money and abundance of bad credit it’s no wonder these two terms are coming up more often. I’m not here to teach you how to broker either one of these deals, but rather just set you straight on what they are, define/clarify some terms  and offer my input on  some of the benefits, risks, etc.

First and most importantly, let’s get the language down first.  A subject to deal is not the same as an assumption which also means the terms are not interchangeable.  Please… stop doing this. You will get yourself into major trouble by promising a deal using one term when what you are really intending to do is another – innocently or not.

SUBJECT TO MORTGAGE
A subject to deal is when you agree to purchase a property subject to the existing mortgage already attached to the property. This means the existing loan will not be satisfied at closing. In a conventional deal, that existing mortgage would be paid off at closing and a satisfaction and release of lien would be recorded by lender. In a subject to deal, nobody is paying off the existing mortgage. It will remain a lien against the property and the lender is going to expect someone to keep making payments. If someone does not make payments the lender will take the property –regardless of what money you paid to the seller, improvements you made, or the fact that your name is on the Deed.

ASSUMPTION OF MORTGAGE
An assumption of mortgage occurs when a lender agrees to let you assume the payment obligations of the current borrower. There are two things to take note of in that sentence 1. An assumption requires lender approval and 2. The existing mortgage is not paid off. The liability of making payments  just shifts.

BENEFITS
If you have very little money to get started in the real estate game, and you are really good at talking people into giving you their property without giving them a bunch of money then I can see why these deals are attractive.

First, there is very little or no money down. You aren’t coming to the table with a big hunk of cash, you aren’t making a down payment, and you aren’t paying lender fees.

Second, if the deal goes bad, you as the investor are not liable to the lender for the defaulted loan. The seller is still the only guarantor of the note; however, heed this warning - you will be named in the foreclosure because your name is on the Deed - Yep. Hmmmm?

RISKS
Pretty much every well constructed loan has a little provision called a Due on Sale clause. This means that in the event the property is sold without lenders approval and without satisfaction of the loan, the lender may call the entire loan due and payable in full - immediately. Get it… Due - On - Sale? 

Many people are aware of their due on sale provision, but are of the opinion that the language is irrelevant. They say things like, “The bank won’t care as long as they are getting their money”.  Well, I am here to tell you that is not entirely true.

Also, think about this...what if your seller files Bankruptcy? After all, he was obviously having a hard time making his mortgage payments. That debt is going to be named in the bankruptcy petition and the trustee is going to want to liquidate that asset which is looking more and more attractive now that you fixed it up.  What if Seller gets hit by a bus and his estate must be probated? Things could get ugly real fast.

Be careful of the representations and guarantees you are making to a seller. The biggest mistake I hear investors make is telling the seller that since the buyer is taking over their mortgage payments the seller will now be free to go out and buy another house. NOT TRUE. Many sellers in a subject do deal believe that you are relieving a debt burden by taking over their payments. While it is true that by you making that mortgage payment seller will have more money in their account at the end of every month, but they are not relieved of the debt. As far as the bank is concerned, the seller (not you) still owes them the full balance of the loan, and it will still appear on their credit report. This means the seller probably can’t go out and get another loan until this one is paid off because their debt load will be too high.  

LEGALITY
Short answer, yes, these are completely legal.  There is no law that says you can not transfer title of your real property without getting permission from your lender first. There may be consequences, but there is no such thing as due on sale jail.

TITLE WORK
You absolutely can (and should) purchase an owners title insurance policy. The coverage will be just like any other deal except the mortgage will be appear in the exceptions part of the policy. It is very possible that if the seller is having a hard time making mortgage payments they are  having a hard time making other payments as well. There are lots of other things that could have attached to the property. Just go ahead and get that title insurance policy. 

GOOD IDEA vs. BAD IDEA
Obviously, if you have a choice, there are much simpler and cleaner ways of purchasing an investment home. However, if a subject to deal is your ticket into real estate investment then remember that full disclosure and transparency are absolutely essential in these transactions. Be sure your seller understands exactly what you are doing and exactly what they are and are not getting. I read an article about an investor who went so far as to require the seller to put down in his own handwriting exactly how he understood the deal to be. This may sound like overkill, but I sure would be glad to have it when some attorney for the seller’s estate starts claiming that I “stole” the property, committed fraud or misrepresented the deal.






Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Example of how House Bill 631 will help Buy and Hold Investors

The Florida Legislature Strengthens Laws to Remove Unwanted Parties from Your Property  The governor signed House Bill 631 into law on March 8, 2018, to update Florida law on ejectment, unlawful detainer, and customary use.   So what does this mean? First, let’s suppose the company owning the building next to yours puts up a fence ten feet over your property line, claiming to have a recorded deed to a strip of your land.  You think the deed is bogus.  To get rid of the fence you would likely file an “ejectment” action.  “Ejectment” is a kind of eviction action in which the party in possession claims a right to be there under a written instrument in its chain of title (usually a deed, easement, or other serious title instrument).  An ejectment action gives you the chance to prove your superior title to the property (after which you would  eject  the neighbor’s fence). Case closed.  The amendments to the Bill modernize the statute to clarify the process and documents necessary to es
Read more

A Blog Series On Land Trusts: Intro

I firmly believe Land Trusts are one of the most misunderstood real estate investment tools nationwide. My plan it to make this a series of posts that will touch on what a land trust is and what it is not, clear up myths and misconceptions and pass along some tips and tricks. It will be basic, but if you understand the basics you can then start to get really specific and use them to cater to your particular investment portfolio.  I haven’t decided how many parts will be in the series so my plan is to just take one topic at a time and see where it leads. First, my back ground with these creatures: If I had to pick something that was “my thing” it would probably be Land Trusts. Never would I have  imagined when I graduated law school this would be the case, but about 6 years ago Debbie Farnell of Southeast Professional Title handed me Mark Warda’s book on the subject and my gears have been turning ever since. In those 6 years or so I have drafted hundreds of land trusts, give
Read more

FAR BAR As-Is Series: Part I

As promised, this is going to start off a short series on the FAR BAR As-Is Contract. I was feeling bad about how long it has taken me to get a new post on here, but it turned out for the best. Last week I gave a short little presentation on the As-Is to a group of investors at the Leverage Connections Network Meeting and the questions from the attendees were fantastic. Their questions made me more aware of what content will be helpful for newbie investors – and some more experienced ones who may have gotten a little lazy. Sorry, truth hurts. Before we get into the terms of the contract let’s first have a quick little discussion about what using an As-Is Contract means. An As-Is offer means the buyer accepts the property in its current As-Is physical condition. That means if the house has a bad roof buyer accepts the responsibility of that roof. It does not mean buyer accepts the fact that there is an open roof permit pulled to fix the roof or that there is a code lien on the p
Read more